On July 4, 2019, the Paris Court of Appeals reduced the fines imposed by the FCA in the “flour” case from €242.4 million to €96.1 million.[1] The Court reduced the fines imposed on the millers while upholding the FCA’s findings on the merits. The total fine reduction was justified by (i) the shorter duration of the infringement for two millers; (ii) the ability to pay for five millers; and (iii) the existence of a price regulation until 1978, which limited the cartel’s impact on the economy.
The FCA Issued Its Second Opinion on French Overseas Territories
On July 4, 2019, the FCA issued an opinion on the functioning of competition for the importation and distribution of consumer products in French overseas territories—one of the FCA’s “priorities” for 2019.[1] The opinion assesses progresses made since the FCA issued its first opinion on French overseas territories, and extends its assessment to online restrictions.
The FCA Fines a Bicycle Manufacturer for an Online Sales Ban
On July 1, 2019 the FCA imposed a fine of €250,000 on the high-end bicycle manufacturer Bikeurope B.V. and its mother company, Trek Bicycle Corporation, for having imposed and monitored an online sales’ ban on its distributors from 2007 to 2014.[1]
The French Supreme Court Annuls an Order of the Paris Court of Appeals Regarding Dawn Raids Conducted at Whirlpool France
In a ruling of June 13, 2019, the French Supreme Court annulled the November 8, 2017 order of the Paris Court of Appeals that confirmed the validity of the search warrants authorizing the French Competition Authority (the “FCA”) to carry out dawn raids at Whirlpool France’s premises.[1]
Complaint Against booking.com and Expedia Brings Hotel Parity Clauses to the Commission’s Docket
On June 11, 2019, Nustay, a Danish online booking agency, filed a complaint with the Commission against Expedia and Booking.com, alleging a breach of Articles 101 and 102 TFEU. The complaint centers on parity clauses in online hotel booking. In 2015, both Expedia and Booking.com agreed with the Danish Competition Authority to remove wide price-parity clauses from their contracts with hotels.[1] Nustay alleges that these two companies have de facto re-introduced these clauses through certain commercial practices.
DCA Finds Narrow MFN Clauses Compatible With Competition Law
On June 4, 2019, the Düsseldorf Court of Appeals (“DCA”) annulled the FCO’s 2015 decision prohibiting hotel booking platform operator Booking Holdings (“Booking.com”) from using narrow most favored nation (“MFN”) clauses.[1] The DCA’s decision aligns the German position with that of other European national competition authorities (“NCAs”). However, new causes of divergence—stemming from legislative interventions—are already emerging.
The Inspection Générale Des Finances and the Conseil Général de L’éConomie Publishes a Report on EU Competition Policy and Industrial Strategy
On June 2, 2019, the Inspection générale des finances and the Conseil général de l’économie published a report on the EU competition policy and industrial strategy (the “Report”). The Report was commissioned by the Ministry of Economy and Finance in December 2018 and aimed at assessing EU competition policy in the context of the 2019 European elections. The Report highlights the necessity to reshape the procedures and legal instruments used by the European Commission, in particular in merger control, to answer a number of criticisms raised by the French and German governments following the decision of the European Commission to prohibit the Alstom- Siemens merger on February 6, 2019.[1] The Report states that competition policy seems to be applied more strictly in Europe than elsewhere, including China, and that the European Union’s strategic and industrial interests should be given more consideration in competition decisions.
The French Competition Authority Fines the Akka Group €0.9 Million for Obstructing Its Investigations During a Dawn Raid
The Commission and the Belgian Competition Authority Simulataneously Raid French and Belgian Grocery Retailers
On May 20, 2019, the Commission carried out dawn raids at the premises of two grocery retailers in France, Casino and Intermarché-Les Mousquetaires.[1] On the same day, the Belgian Competition Authority raided Carrefour and Provera, a joint purchasing venture of grocery retailers Cora, Match, and Louis Delhaize. Although the two series of dawn raids occurred simultaneously, the Commission’s press release leaves open whether the raids were coordinated.
British Steel/Ascoval
On May 17, 2019, the French Competition Authority (the “FCA”) unconditionally approved the acquisition of Ascoval by the British Steel group. Ascoval is a steel mill specialized in the production and supply of semi-finished steel products that are necessary for the production of finished steel products. British Steel is a European steel manufacturer that is active in the production of both semi-finished and finished steel products. Given the limited overlap between the Parties’ activities, the FCA did not identify any horizontal or vertical competition concerns arising from the transaction.